News

The antique optometer

Last month Henry Burek posed the puzzle of the antique optometer and here he explains his solution. The first correct answer to be drawn out of the hat came from Alkesh Kukadia of Leicester who wins 1,000 EyeMiles from Inspecs. Well done Noel Evans, David Ehrlich, Richard Edge, Barbara Jarman, Neil Constantine-Smith and Ross Turner who also solved the puzzle

The power range of the device is ±10.00 DS. Each lens holder has lenses of equal power but opposite sign:

Holder 1: +0.25 DS and -0.25 DS
Holder 2: +0.75 DS and -0.75 DS
Holder 3: +2.25 DS and -2.25 DS
Holder 4: +6.75 DS and -6.75 DS

This particular selection of lenses produces a unique power for every unique permutation of the lens holders, thereby ensuring the maximum possible range.
With this combination any sphere power from -10.00 up to +10.00 can be created. For example +8.25 can be created by combining -0.75, +2.25 and +6.75.
The easiest way to solve this is to it tackle in stages: what would be the maximum range achievable using only one lens holder? The lenses would have to be +0.25 and -0.25 to achieve the stated requirements. A trivial situation.
The next step is to consider what single plus lens added to the range already available (-0.25 to +0.25) extends the range without duplicating any powers already available. What plus lens power added to the most minus power already available (-0.25) gives the next required power in the plus range (+0.50)? The answer is +0.75. The same argument applied to extending the minus range deduces that -0.75 should be the companion lens. Thus, the lenses required in the second lens holder are +0.75 and -0.75. The maximum range available with just two lens holders is -1.00 to +1.00.
The same process applied sequentially to the third and fourth lens holders reveals these should hold the lens pairs ±2.25 and ±6.75.
A practical upshot of this puzzle has a bearing on the choice of plus-minus twirls, flippers or confirmation tests used in practice. Most practitioners have a ±0.25 set and a ±0.50 set, and most practitioners will have had occasion to combine both together in contact to use as a ±0.75 set. It's better to have a ±0.25 set and a ±0.75 set, then, you have access to ±0.25, ±0.50, ±0.75 and ±1.00!

Register now to continue reading

Thank you for visiting Optician Online. Register now to access up to 10 news and opinion articles a month.

Register

Already have an account? Sign in here

Related Articles